Wave 1
Wave 1A: opened June 7
- The Stand vs. Pet Sematary: 53 votes (77.94%) vs. 9 votes (13.24%)
- The Drawing of the Three vs. The Talisman: 37 votes (52.11%) vs. 28 votes (39.44%)
- It vs. Different Seasons: 46 votes (71.88%) vs. 12 votes (18.75%)
- The Shining vs. 'Salem's Lot: 30 votes (46.88%) vs. 25 votes (39.06%)
- The Green Mile vs. The Waste Lands: 18 votes (26.47%) vs. 40 votes (58.82%)
Wave 1B: opened June 8
- The Talisman vs. The Stand: 14 votes (21.54%) vs. 44 votes (67.69%)
- Pet Sematary vs. Different Seasons: 26 votes (41.27%) vs. 30 votes (47.62%)
- The Drawing of the Three vs. 'Salem's Lot: 36 votes (53.73%) vs. 26 votes (38.81%)
- It vs. The Waste Lands: 41 votes (57.75%) vs. 28 votes (39.44%)
- The Shining vs. The Green Mile: 31 votes (50.00%) vs. 23 votes (37.10%)
Wave 1C: opened June 9
- The Stand vs. Different Seasons: 52 votes (80.00%) vs. 8 votes (12.31%)
- The Talisman vs. 'Salem's Lot: 32 votes (48.48%) vs. 26 votes (39.39%)
- Pet Sematary vs. The Waste Lands: 20 votes (29.85%) vs. 43 votes (64.18%)
- The Drawing of the Three vs. The Green Mile: 45 votes (63.38%) vs. 19 votes (26.76%)
- It vs. The Shining: 46 votes (71.88%) vs 15 votes (23.44%)
Wave 2
Wave 2A: opened June 14
- 'Salem's Lot vs. The Stand: 8 votes (15.38%) vs. 38 votes (73.08%)
- Different Seasons vs. The Waste Lands: 15 votes (28.85%) vs. 33 votes (63.46%)
- The Talisman vs. The Green Mile: 24 votes (48.98%) vs. 16 votes (32.65%)
- Pet Sematary vs. The Shining: 20 votes (39.22%) vs. 22 votes (43.14%)
- The Drawing of the Three vs. It: 26 votes (46.43%) vs. 28 votes (50.00%)
Wave 2B: opened June 15
- The Stand vs. The Waste Lands: 39 votes (63.93%) vs. 19 votes (31.15%)
- 'Salem's Lot vs. The Green Mile: 28 votes (50.91%) vs. 19 votes (34.55%)
- Different Seasons vs. The Shining: 21 votes (35.59%) vs. 31 votes (52.54%)
- The Talisman vs. It: 10 votes (28.57%) vs. 21 votes (60.00%)
- Pet Sematary vs. The Drawing of the Three: 20 votes (36.36%) vs. 31 votes (56.36%)
Wave 2C: opened June 16
- The Green Mile vs. The Stand: 4 votes (6.90%) vs. 46 votes (79.31%)
- The Waste Lands vs. The Shining: 39 votes (63.93%) vs. 18 votes (29.51%)
- 'Salem's Lot vs. It: 13 votes (22.81%) vs. 38 votes (66.67%)
- Different Seasons vs. The Drawing of the Three: 18 votes (30.00%) vs. 37 votes (61.67%)
- The Talisman vs. Pet Sematary: 25 votes (45.45%) vs. 23 votes (41.82%)
Wave 3
Wave 3A: opened June 23
- The Stand vs. The Shining: 50 votes (75.76%) vs. 9 votes (13.64%)
- The Green Mile vs. It: 18 votes (28.13%) vs. 38 votes (59.38%)
- The Waste Lands vs. The Drawing of the Three: 39 votes (53.42%) vs. 34 votes (46.58%)
- 'Salem's Lot vs. Pet Sematary: 33 votes (54.10%) vs. 19 votes (31.15%)
- Different Seasons vs. The Talisman: 18 votes (29.51%) vs. 32 votes (52.46%)
Wave 3B: opened June 24
- It vs. The Stand: 23 votes (31.08%) vs. 47 votes (63.51%)
- The Shining vs. The Drawing of the Three: 30 votes (40.00%) vs. 40 votes (53.33%)
- The Green Mile vs. Pet Sematary: 30 votes (42.25%) vs. 31 votes (43.66%)
- The Waste Lands vs. The Talisman: 42 votes (57.53%) vs. 25 votes (34.25%)
- 'Salem's Lot vs. Different Seasons: 34 votes (50.75%) vs. 22 votes (32.84%)
Wave 3C: opened June 25
- The Stand vs. The Drawing of the Three: 48 votes (68.57%) vs. 19 votes (27.14%)
- It vs. Pet Sematary: 42 votes (62.69%) vs. 17 votes (25.37%)
- The Shining vs. The Talisman: 21 votes (33.33%) vs. 32 votes (50.79%)
- The Green Mile vs. Different Seasons: 28 votes (43.08%) vs. 24 votes (36.92%)
- The Waste Lands vs. 'Salem's Lot: 43 votes (62.32%) vs. 21 votes (30.43%)